
Search this blog
The most popular post
Comments
I welcome general comments about this blog and comments about individual posts. All comments should be sent to: the German nickname for Friedrich followed by the surname of the Austrian economist and Nobel laureate with the given name Friedrich followed by the last two digits of his birth year, all run together without spaces or punctuation, followed by the usual typographic symbol and "gmail.com" (without the quotation marks).
I may choose to reply to comments by blogging about them. In such cases, I may edit or paraphrase comments.
In any event, I will not mention a correspondent's name unless he or she expressly authorizes me to do so. Even then, I will treat the name as a pseudonym by placing it in quotation marks, unless I have certain knowledge of the correspondent's real name.
On Liberty
What is liberty? It is peaceful, willing coexistence and its concomitant: beneficially cooperative behavior.
John Stuart Mill opined that "the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others." But who determines whether an act is harmful or harmless? Acts deemed harmless by an individual are not harmless if they subvert the societal bonds of trust and self-restraint upon which liberty itself depends.
Which is not to say that all social regimes are regimes of liberty. Liberty requires voice -- the freedom to dissent -- and exit -- the freedom to choose one's neighbors and associates. Voice and exit depend, in turn, on the rule of law under a minimal state.
Liberty, because it is a social phenomenon and not an innate condition of humanity, must be won and preserved by an unflinching defense of a polity that fosters liberty through its norms, and the swift and certain administration of justice within that polity.
The governments of the United States and most States have long since ceased to foster liberty, but Americans are hostage in their own land and have no choice but to strive for the restoration of liberty, or something closer to it.
Notes about usage
"State" (with a capital "S") refers to one of the United States, and "States" refers to two or more of them. "State" and "States," thus used, are proper nouns because they refer to a unique entity or entities: one or more of the United States, the union of which, under the terms and conditions stated in the Constitution, is the raison d’être for the nation. I reserve the uncapitalized word "state" for a government, or hierarchy of them, which exerts a monopoly of force within its boundaries.
The words "liberal," "progressive," and their variants are in quotation marks because they refer to persons and movements whose statist policies are, in fact, destructive of liberty and progress.
Marriage, in the Western tradition, predates the state and legitimates the union of one man and one woman. As such, it is an institution that is vital to civil society and therefore to the enjoyment of liberty. The recognition of a more-or-less permanent homosexual pairing as a kind of marriage is both ill-advised and illegitimate. Such an arrangement is therefore a "marriage" (in quotation marks) or, more accurately, a homosexual cohabitation contract (HCC).
Recent Posts
- Irrational Rationality
- Lay My (Regulatory) Burden Down
- Are the Natural Numbers Supernatural?
- Liberty, Negative Rights, and Bleeding Hearts
- “Men’s Health”
- The Real Multiplier (II)
- Countdown to Election 2012 (2nd Post)
- Bonds for the Long Run?
- Legislating Morality
- Are You in the Bubble?
- Denseness about Density
- Prohibition, Abortion, and “Progressivism”
- A Nation of (Unconstitutional) Laws
- In Defense of the 1%
- Estimating the Rahn Curve: A Sequel
Archives
- February 2012 (9)
- January 2012 (15)
- December 2011 (16)
- November 2011 (23)
- October 2011 (21)
- September 2011 (26)
- August 2011 (31)
- July 2011 (26)
- June 2011 (18)
- May 2011 (11)
- April 2011 (10)
- March 2011 (17)
- February 2011 (18)
- January 2011 (18)
- December 2010 (15)
- November 2010 (20)
- October 2010 (21)
- September 2010 (21)
- August 2010 (16)
- July 2010 (14)
- June 2010 (16)
- May 2010 (21)
- April 2010 (15)
- March 2010 (7)
- December 2009 (3)
- November 2009 (2)
- October 2009 (8)
- September 2009 (9)
- August 2009 (13)
- July 2009 (15)
- June 2009 (11)
- May 2009 (14)
- April 2009 (12)
- March 2009 (10)
- February 2009 (5)
Categories
- Cultural Commentary (71)
- Economics – Fundamentals (105)
- Economics – Growth & Decline (76)
- Electoral Politics (66)
- Political Economy & Civil Society (211)
- Political Movements & Theories (63)
- Reportage (14)
- Rule of Law (124)
- Science and Understanding (70)
- War & Peace (58)
Most-used tags
Blogroll
- Agoraphilia
- Americana, Etc. my blog about baseball, films, trivia, nostalgia, and suchlike
- Arts & Letters Daily
- Barone, Michael
- Bench Memos (National Review)
- Blaze, The – Blog
- Blaze, The – Stories
- Bleeding Heart Libertarians
- bluebird of bitterness
- Cafe Hayek
- Carpe Diem (Mark J. Perry)
- Cato @ Liberty
- Cato Unbound
- City Journal
- Congress Shall Make No Law (Institute for Justice)
- Coordination Problem
- Dissecting Leftism (John J. Ray)
- Diversity Insight
- Downsizing the Federal Government
- Dyspepsia Generation
- EconLog
- Enterprise Blog, The (AEI)
- Feser, Edward
- Foundry, The (Heritage Foundation)
- Goodman, John – Health Policy Blog
- Greenie Watch (John J. Ray)
- Grumpy Economist, The (John Cochrane)
- Hanson, Victor Davis
- Hurricane Spaghetti Models tropical systems: satellite, radar, and forecast tracks
- Ideas (David Friedman)
- Knowledge Problem
- Landsburg, Steven: The Big Questions
- Liberty Corner the predecessor of Politics & Prosperity
- Liberty Corner, The Original a reconstruction of the pre-blog version of Liberty Corner
- LifeNews.com
- Mankiw, Greg – Blog
- Maverick Philosopher (Bill Vallicella)
- McArdle, Megan: The Atlantic
- Originalism Blog, The
- Political Calculations
- Political Correctness Watch (John J. Ray)
- Public Discourse
- RealClearPolitics
- Return to Rome (Francis J. Beckwith)
- Right Coast, The
- Social Affairs Unit, The
- Spencer, Roy (Ph.D.)
- Steyn, Mark
- ThinkMarkets
- Via Meadia (Walter Russell Mead)
- Vociferous Reader, The (Matthew Anger)
- Volokh Conspiracy, The
- Watts Up With That?
- Wilkinson, Will – The Compleat
About the blogroll
Aside from four other blogs of mine (three of them inactive), the blogroll includes only those blogs and news feeds that I read regularly. The roll will change from time to time, as I discover sites that offer fresh perspectives in clear, engaging prose, and as I prune sites that are no longer of interest to me. I do not exchange links.
The inclusion of a blog does not connote endorsement. Several blogs are on the roll because they are provocatively wrong-headed and spur me to write posts in rebuttal.
The Left’s Agenda
February 16, 2011 Leave a Comment
A post at Bookworm Room caught my eye:
Why have American leftists so eagerly embraced Islam, with all of its ugly features, while rejecting pro-Western Israel? What is the left’s agenda with respect to Islam and Israel? What is the left’s agenda, period?
Don’t expect to understand the left by looking for rational explanations of leftist beliefs and behavior. The left is in an arrested state of adolescent rebellion: “If it’s ‘bad’ or dangerous, I want it, just to be ‘different’ (well, not different from my peers, whose approval I seek) and to express my ‘independence’ (as long as ‘Daddy government’ gives me an allowance, birthday presents, cell phones, etc.).”
To put it bluntly — and this is entirely consistent with my experience — persons of the left are like unthinking, selfish adolescents who want what they want, regardless of the consequences for themselves or others.
It seems natural for adolescents and young adults to flirt with leftism. The persistence of leftism beyond one’s twenties is a sign of arrested emotional development. (By the way, I would say the same thing about doctrinaire libertarian extremists, the kind who believe in fairy tales about stateless societies.)
Related posts:
The Left
Intelligence, Personality, Politics, and Happiness
Bounded Liberty: A Thought Experiment
Share this:
Like this:
Filed under Cultural Commentary Tagged with adolescent rebellion, leftism, the left